by | November 16, 2026
How Prissy Elrod’s Good Deed Led to a Broken Nose From a Culprit Who Can’t Talk
Stepping in to help is second nature. Recovering from it took eight weeks for humorist Prissy Elrod.
Whether first uttered by Clare Boothe Luce or another exhausted soul centuries ago, the old saying “no good deed goes unpunished” has survived for a reason.
Maybe because so many of us have lived it. Especially me, I would argue.
As one of my favorite Florida authors, Carl Hiaasen, once said, “You just can’t make this stuff up.” That should be confirmation enough that my stories are true.

It all began on a beautiful April day in Tallahassee, home to the worst pollen in the state of Florida, according to me. My morning routine was sneezing, blowing my nose and swallowing Claritin before coffee. Plus, we were in the middle of a drought. Looking out the window, everything was dusted yellow. My gray car, the porch furniture, even a scurrying squirrel looked tinted.
Around that same time, I volunteered to stay at my daughter’s house while she and her husband celebrated their wedding anniversary abroad. My assignment was simple: spend the first six nights of their 10-day trip with my 14-year-old grandson, Raynes. Each day meant getting him off to school, picking him up afterward and shuttling him to whatever activity filled his afternoon.
Truth be told, I’m not sure which one of us was doing the overseeing. Raynes and I are remarkably alike, which is either charming or exhausting, depending on who’s judging. We’re both optimistic beings, chronic grazers, insomniacs and hopeless people-pleasers. We wake up happy and stay busy all day. Sometimes we even forget to eat.
Prior to my Raynes commitment, my so-called bosses overruled my request to also take care of their Havanese puppy, Poppy, at home with us. “No way you’re keeping that dog. It’s way too much work,” my younger daughter said. My husband joined the opposition. “Poppy goes if you stay.”
So I boarded myself at my older daughter’s house while Poppy boarded elsewhere for the duration of my stay. Kenley, Raynes’s older sister, would drive from the University of Florida to relieve me, rescue Poppy from her temporary incarceration and stay with Raynes for the last leg of their parents’ trip.
Perfect plan. Wrong.
The day before my duty was to end, guilt got the better of me. All I could picture was Poppy’s little face peering through kennel bars those previous days and nights, wondering what she’d done wrong. My pleasing gene took over, as it so often does.
I ignored my board of directors’ decision and picked up Poppy a day early to surprise Raynes. When he climbed into my car after school, Poppy launched into his arms. All that joy, love and enthusiasm convinced me I’d done the right thing.
Back home, Raynes and Poppy headed out for a long neighborhood walk before her fur-scrubbing bath. Afterward, each devoured two helpings of my chicken and rice and went to bed, happy and together.
My pleasing gene took over, as it so often does.
—Prissy Elrod
I woke up early the next morning, eager to head home to my own bed and coffee pot. Kenley was already driving from Gainesville, according to my tracking app, so I stripped the bed and remade it with fresh sheets. I wanted to leave everything spic-and-span for my daughter, who inherited just enough OCD from me to appreciate such things.
My arms loaded with king-size sheets, I shuffled to the laundry room in my oversized UGG slippers. They are comfortably ugly, hence the clever brand name.
I was airborne before I could blink. My nose landed first and took the brunt of the faceplant before the rest of me arrived.
“Raynes!” I hollered.
He came running down the stairs to find me sprawled on the floor with a bloody nose. Ten minutes later, Kenley walked in to the same scene. Both were traumatized.
The emergency room confirmed what my face already knew: broken nose. Two places.
Their instructions were brief. “Eight weeks.” “Don’t blow nose.” “Don’t sneeze with mouth closed.” I left with a referral for a maxillofacial surgeon to patch me up.
Eight weeks? For Pete’s sake, it was pollen season. They may as well have told Tallahassee Sassy not to breathe until June.
I braved it and wore my crooked nose and bruised complexion with a smile.
—Prissy Elrod
The trauma surgeon said surgery was optional since my breathing wasn’t affected. Fortunately, my vanity behaved that day, so I declined surgery. Truthfully, cowardice won, and since my pointed nose had saved the rest of my head, I figured it was owed the grace.
Nobody warned me bruises migrate. Every morning, I awoke to find they’d traveled overnight—from nose to eye, eye to cheek, cheek to jaw, eventually wandering south toward my neck.
Days later, I celebrated my birthday, thankful I was still alive another year at that point.
Unfortunately, my calendar appointments were inked in, so my commitments couldn’t be erased. First came a book club that had selected my book “Far Outside the Ordinary” as their monthly read. I braved it and wore my crooked nose and bruised complexion with a smile. A small group of wine-drinking ladies was exactly what I needed. Looking back, I probably spent more time talking about my upside-down calamity than the book they’d invited me to discuss.
By Memorial Day, the bruises had finally faded. The pollen was easing, and I was convinced the worst was behind me. If only.
June arrived swinging. I became sicker than I can remember being in years. Urgent care discovered a middle ear infection. An antibiotic was prescribed. I was sick all night. Then came nerve pain that shot through my head, ear and neck like an electric knife.
Six weeks earlier they had forbidden me to blow my nose during the worst pollen season in memory. Now, every backed-up allergy symptom had united and was festering inside my head.
For eight years, I have worn professionally inserted ear tubes, but then came the real surprise. The doctor discovered the tube I assumed was still in my eardrum had quietly moved and was embedded in my ear canal. My ENT physician plucked it out, and just like that, tube No. 10 went in.
I no longer carried a social calendar. I carried a medical one. I measured time not by weeks but by appointments. One specialist became four. Antibiotics led to injections. My chiropractor blamed my neck. Physical therapy blamed my fall. My dentist blamed my bite. Everyone blamed someone.
Thankfully, I eventually recovered. The pollen packed up and left town. The specialists went back to treating their regular patients. Life settled into something that once again resembled ordinary. But my nose does check in from time to time, just to make sure I haven’t forgotten it.
Looking back, I’ve gained another reminder that life has a peculiar sense of humor. I’ve also learned that kindness comes with no guarantees, and sometimes a good deed comes with consequences. Every now and then it leaves you with a broken nose, 10 ear tubes, a medical appointment every day of the week and a ridiculous tale to tell. As for what really launched my fall that morning? Some secrets are worth keeping to oneself. And I’m dog-gone grateful the only eyewitness can’t talk
For more looks into Prissy Elrod’s mind, click here.
About the Author
Prissy is a professional speaker, artist and humorist, and the author of two nonfiction books: “Far Outside the Ordinary” and “Chasing Ordinary,” the sequel. She was born and raised in Lake City and now lives in Tallahassee with her husband, Dale.